City Cast DC logo

Where To Get Your Thanksgiving Pie

Posted on November 14, 2022   |   Updated on September 30, 2025
Kaela Cote-Stemmermann

Kaela Cote-Stemmermann

A lone piece of sweet potato pie. (Matty Jasperson/Getty Images)

A lone piece of sweet potato pie. (Matty Jasperson/Getty Images)

Homemade pies are great, but if you show up to friendsgiving with one of these? You’ll be the hero of the night.

🥧 Pie Shop – This H St. pastry shop ONLY does pies, so they have a ton of variety, both sweet and savory. Grab an apple pie or something different like the berger cookie pie or winterberry crumble. ($36 each)

🍎 Little Red Fox – Although the café doesn’t typically carry pies, they go all out on holidays. Choose between double-crusted apple, pumpkin, key lime, or bourbon pecan. ($30 each)

🎃 Bread Furst – Your favorite bakery has three special pies for the season: pumpkin, apple, and pecan bourbon. ($32 each)

🍠 Henry’s Soul Café – There is only one pie on the menu at Henry’s — but that's all you need. Their sweet potato pie is infamous. Get one before they're gone. ($13.99 each)🫐 Acme Pie Co. – Acme sells its sweets at markets and restaurants in D.C. and Virginia, but they also do Thanksgiving orders and have a variety of classics. Their apple and berry pies are vegan. (Price varies)

Share article

Hey DC

Get smart about D.C. with our news roundup and analysis.

Can't subscribe? Turn off your ad blocker and try again.

Obsessed

See All

The latest in DC

The DC DispatchMay 15

Pirro Says She Will Prosecute Parents of Kids Participating in "Teen Takeovers"

U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro said parents could face fines or up to six months of jail time.

US Attorney for the District of Columbia Jeanine Pirro and US Acting Attorney General Todd Blanche. (Annabelle Gordon/AFP via Getty Images)
AnnouncementsMay 12

Kaela Cote-Stemmermann Is City Cast DC’s New Food and Culture Reporter

City Cast DC is undergoing an unprecedented expansion of its local newsroom, hiring a team of journalists to create original reporting ab...

The DC DispatchMay 12

"Downright scandalous:" Inside the NSFW text messages that got a top D.C. police official put on leave

An internal report shows ex-executive assistant chief Andre Wright repeatedly sent crude texts and mocked colleagues.

An internal report shows ex-executive assistant chief Andre Wright repeatedly sent crude texts and mocked colleagues. (Saul Loeb/AFP via Getty Images)
The DC DispatchMay 5

Police Chief: 13 Top Officials Face Termination Amid Crime Stats Scandal

Jeffery Carroll also confirmed the restructuring of the department.

Interim MPD Chief of Police Jeffery Carroll.
The DC DispatchMay 4

Multiple D.C. Police Leaders Face Termination Over Crime Data Manipulation

The changes could constitute a sweeping restructuring of department leadership.

Metropolitan Police Department outside of Nationals Park on August 15, 2025. (Kayla Bartkowski/Getty Images)
AnnouncementsMay 4

We're launching two new newsletters

Sign up now to get the big stories Washington is talking about and our can't-miss guide to food and culture.

DC, ExplainedMay 4

The Obama musical returns Washingtonians to an old, hopeful DC

This raunchy love letter to 2008 D.C. by a former Obama campaign staffer left us weeping with laughter and nostalgia.

TJ Wilkins starring as Barack Obama sings “How Black Is Too Black?” (Courtesy of “44”)
DC Life HacksApril 30

Your Guide to DC in May 2026

So bust out your social planner, here’s our 🔥 super hot 🔥 monthly guide to the District for May.

Union Market drive-in movies. (The Washington Post/Getty Images)